Three unusual questions to make job candidates think

Interviews often default to predictable questions that lead to equally predictable answers. Here’s how to get some meaningful insights into what makes people tick.

Interviews often default to predictable questions that lead to equally predictable answers. Here’s how to get some meaningful insights into what makes people tick.

For the last dozen years, in hundreds of interviews, I’ve tried to better understand how CEOs hire by asking them: if you could ask a candidate only one question in a job interview, and you had to decide based on their answer whether to hire them, what would that question be?

Yes, I heard familiar questions, such as, “What are your greatest strengths and weaknesses?” and “What are you passionate about?” But my line of inquiry also led to some surprising replies:

On a scale of 1 to 10, how weird are you?

If you were a beverage, what would be your defining characteristics?

How would you describe yourself in one word?

Because people interviewing for senior jobs have faced questions so often as they climb the corporate ladder, most have had practice delivering polished answers to the more predictable ones. You can bet that a lot of people will respond, “I care too much,” when asked their biggest weakness.

And so, almost out of necessity, interviewers have to come up with what I call “bank-shot questions” to peek behind the facades that people present in interviews, so it’s easier to find out what really makes them tick. What’s great about this type of question is that there are no right or wrong answers, and people can’t try to game the system, especially when they explain why they answered the way they did. This led me to wonder: what would be the best single question? Here are my top three from the many I’ve heard.

Continue reading…

The ExCo Group’s Adam Bryant wrote this article for his column in Strategy + Business.

More from Our Art of Leading Series

ART OF LEADING

I Don’t Like Indirection. I Want Feedback. Give Me The Good, The Bad, The Ugly.

With Guy Yehiav

with Guy Yehiav, President of SmartSense by Digi

ART OF LEADING

I Really Value People Who Look For Ways To Contribute Beyond Their Job Description

With Dave Katz

with Dave Katz, President and Chief Operating Officer at Coca-Cola Consolidated

ART OF LEADING

When I Hire Someone, I Empower Them Completely And Give Them 100% Support

With Janet Garcia

with Janet Garcia, CEO of PSI Services

Subscribe to our Interview Series on LinkedIn

B Suite

Leading in the B-suite

Powerful conversations about life, race and leadership.

Leading in the B-suite

Go to LinkedIn

Strategic CHRO

Strategic CHRO

Conversations with leaders who are transforming the world of HR

Strategic CHRO

Go to LinkedIn

The Director’s Chair

The Director’s Chair

Conversations with leaders about changing board dynamics in an age of disruption

The Director’s Chair

Go to LinkedIn

AI Plus

AI + Leadership

Transformative conversations on the implications of AI in leadership

AI + Leadership

Go to LinkedIn

Art of Leading

Art of Leading

Powerful insights from top leaders

Art of Leading

Go to LinkedIn